This case takes place in New York and involves a school bus involved in an accident that resulted in serious injuries to several students. The school bus was traveling with members of a high school basketball team who were returning from a game at the time of the incident. The bus was driving on a street that had a 45 mile-an-hour speed limit, and ran through a wooded area. The bus had just pulled around a turn when it hit several deer that had been standing in the roadway. It was at this point that the driver lost control of the bus, which careened into the woods on the side of the road and impacted a large tree. Due to the force of the impact, several students were thrown from their seats and sustained serious injuries. It is alleged that the school bus should have been equipped with seat belts, and that the presence of seat belts would have prevented many of the injuries suffered by students as a result of the accident.
Question(s) For Expert Witness
1. Are you familiar with school bus seat belt laws?
2. Do you have the expertise to discuss the pros and cons of seat belts on school buses?
3. Are you familiar with the concept of compartmentalization?
Expert Witness Response E-009104
I have a great deal of familiarity with school bus seat belt laws and compartmentalization. Prior to 2005, school bus seat belt laws were not enforced, and no one enforces the wearing of the seat belts or how they're fastened. Schools can not demand that students wear seat belts on buses, and there is even a clause that state that the board of education can override a ruling for students to wear seat belts on buses. Older buses will never have and are never required to have seat belts if they were made before 2015. As far as I'm concerned, given the brief description, this is a case definitely more favorable for the defendant. The bus company is conforming with the federal law and there is really no responsibility to retrofit a school bus with seat belts. As for compartmentalization, if these seats are close enough to one another and rigidly mounted to the floor, that also voids the need for seat belts.
About the author
Joseph O'Neill
Joe has extensive experience in online journalism and technical writing across a range of legal topics, including personal injury, meidcal malpractice, mass torts, consumer litigation, commercial litigation, and more. Joe spent close to six years working at Expert Institute, finishing up his role here as Director of Marketing. He has considerable knowledge across an array of legal topics pertaining to expert witnesses. Currently, Joe servces as Owner and Demand Generation Consultant at LightSail Consulting.
