How Expert Radar Helped Secure a $413K Verdict

When a young woman suffered permanent injuries after a rear-end collision with a tractor-trailer, the trucking company admitted fault but disputed whether the crash could have caused her injuries.

The defense's biomechanical expert argued that the collision generated insufficient force to cause the reported injuries, pointing to minimal vehicle damage.

For trial attorney Jonny Akchin of Warnken, LLC, challenging that testimony became a critical part of the case.

"Our case was centered on the permanence of the injuries and their lasting impact on the life of a very young person," Akchin explained.

Uncovering Patterns With Expert Radar

Akchin turned to Expert Radar to investigate the defense expert's litigation history, prior testimony, and potential patterns in his opinions.

The research helped the team identify 23 prior expert reports using the same methodology, including five prepared for the law firm representing the defense. According to Akchin, every report concluded that the forces involved were insufficient to cause injury.

Armed with these documents, the attorneys conducted additional AI-assisted analysis, uncovering remarkably similar language across reports involving different accident circumstances.

In one instance, descriptions of two distinctly different accident victims were approximately 99% identical. The team also discovered the same unusual typo repeated across five reports.

These findings raised questions about whether the expert's conclusions reflected independent, case-specific analysis.

Turning Research Into Trial Strategy

During cross-examination, Akchin asked the expert if his report was written after a completely independent, rigorous review of the specific facts of the case. The expert agreed, and admitted that it would be unprofessional to rubber-stamp a conclusion before such a rigorous review, and just as unprofessional to take a report from another case, plug in a new name and vehicle information, and keep the conclusions exactly the same.

Akchin then confronted the expert with the identical fact and conclusion language, challenged his claimed neutrality, and questioned the consistency of his conclusions.

The expert was asked to read nearly identical passages from separate reports aloud to the jury. As Akchin recalled, "He read both paragraphs aloud to the jury and admitted that they were very similar."

Akchin also highlighted the repeated typographical errors as further evidence of potentially standardized reporting.

According to Akchin, jurors visibly lost confidence in the witness as the questioning progressed.

"The Radar report gave us the aggregate data to back up what we already knew."

The attorney also emphasized the value of combining comprehensive litigation records with AI analysis, which helped identify patterns that "an army of document review staff might have missed."

The Impact of Expert Radar

Expert Radar provided the underlying litigation records that made this cross-examination possible, allowing the legal team to move beyond challenging a single expert opinion and examine the consistency of the expert's work across numerous cases.

By uncovering prior reports, recurring conclusions, and potential inconsistencies, the attorneys developed targeted questions supported by the expert's own documented history.

For attorneys preparing to challenge opposing experts, the case demonstrates how comprehensive expert due diligence can reveal critical insights, strengthen cross-examination strategies, and help expose weaknesses in expert testimony.

Explore Expert Radar to learn how expert witness research can strengthen your case preparation.

Visit Jonny’s Bio Page to learn more about Maryland trial lawyer Jonny Akchin.