This case involves a sixty-two-year-old male patient who presented to the hospital with a displacement of a cervical intervertebral disc and was admitted to the neurosurgery service after a workup revealed cervical spinal stenosis, cervical myelomalacia, and cervical spondylosis. The patient underwent an anterior discectomy and fusion at C5/C6 and C6/C7, with SSEP and MEP monitoring in place throughout the operative procedure. The operative note described the removal of a significant amount of osteophytes and the use of plates and screws to secure the fusion. The procedure was conducted without incident and a stage two spinal stabilization procedure was scheduled for the following week. The second procedure was conducted but this time MEP monitoring was not employed. The patient awoke from surgery with a paralyzed right upper extremity. A CT scan was performed that showed no neuro laminal vertebral, foraminal, or central canal encroachment from metallic hardware. EMG and nerve conduction studies were done and conclusions were that there was electrophysiologic evidence of bilateral brachial plexopathies with widespread active denervation in all tested muscles innervated from C5 to T1. The patient had a diagnosis of bilateral brachial plexopathy with the left side being injured to a much lesser extent and is currently undergoing rehabilitation with minimal improvement.