Alleged Racial Discrimination in California Firefighter Training

This case study explores an alleged racial discrimination incident during a firefighter training and testing process in California, where the plaintiff's re-test was abruptly terminated for unidentifiable safety issues.

ByExpert Institute


Published on February 6, 2024

Firefighter jackets and helmets hanging

Case Overview

This case study delves into an alleged racial discrimination incident involving a firefighter trainee during the testing process in California. The plaintiff, along with several other trainees, initially failed the test but was given a second chance to re-test. However, the plaintiff’s re-test was abruptly terminated, and points were deducted for supposed safety issues.

Intriguingly, the grader could not later identify these alleged safety issues. If these deductions had not been made, the plaintiff should have passed alongside their fellow trainees. This case seeks an expert opinion on firefighter training and testing standards in California to ascertain potential liability.

Questions to the expert and their responses


Can you describe your experience with firefighter training and testing standards in California?

I hold a master’s degree in public administration and an associate of applied science in fire management. I’ve served as assistant chief of both training and personnel divisions. I provided first-hand training, experience, and best practices in developing standards, recruiting training, and personnel investigations.

With nearly 30 years of service in the fire department, including 9 years as fire chief and 7 years as deputy or battalion chief specializing in fire training, I’ve overseen hundreds of trainees’ hiring, training or grading processes.


What standards exist when evaluating trainees' test results compared to fellow trainees in California?

The specifics can vary depending on the department and its policies; however, generally speaking, all trainees are evaluated based on their ability to meet established performance benchmarks that reflect essential job functions.

About the expert

This expert brings to the table 25 years of extensive experience in firefighting, having served in various leadership roles such as fire captain, fire training officer, and fire battalion chief. They hold a BA in Political Science, an AA in Fire Science Management, and an MA in Public Administration, supplemented with additional coursework in hazardous waste operations and emergency response. Currently serving as the deputy fire chief for a major county in California and running their own fire and public safety consultancy, this expert's comprehensive knowledge and practical experience make them highly relevant to the case study involving firefighter training standards.

Expert headshot



About the author

Find an expert witness near you

What State is your case in?

What party are you representing?