01

Current Workplace Health & Safety Concerns

Many essential medical workers have no choice but to risk contracting COVID-19 as they work to save the lives of others. At other companies, however, corporate leadership decisions may be exposing workers to unnecessary health and safety risks.

Current workplace health and safety concerns include employer failure to comply with CDC guidelines for safe working conditions, lack of sufficient personal protective equipment (PPE), inability to practice social distancing measures, and inflexible or non-existent paid sick leave policies.

02

Open COVID-19 Workplace Safety Lawsuits

A wrongful death lawsuit against retailer Walmart was filed in Illinois on April 6, 2020, alleging that Walmart’s “willful and wanton misconduct and reckless disregard” for the health and safety of its workers caused the death of a stock and maintenance department employee. Walmart is considered an “essential business” under the Department of Homeland Security’s guidance. But the company is also responsible for adhering to OSHA and CDC guidelines in order to protect their thousands of employees working through a pandemic. The lawsuit against Walmart claims that the company failed to meet any of these standards.

Other companies may face similar lawsuits, as well as workers’ compensation claims related to employee illnesses. Amazon has made headlines recently for allegedly firing a whistleblowing employee who staged a walkout demanding paid leave and deep cleaning of the warehouse in which he worked. Similarly, over 200 Spectrum Cable employees tested positive for COVID-19 after the company refused to let them work remotely, ignoring social distancing guidelines. More recently, Tyson Foods has come under fire for its failure to protect employees from contracting COVID-19 in meatpacking plants across the country. Nearly 5,000 of Tyson’s employees have fallen ill with COVID-19, and 18 have died.

03

The Landscape of COVID-19 Occupational Hazard Claims

Even in the midst of record unemployment, workers’ compensation is directly impacted in the frequency and severity of claims. In analysis by the National Council on Compensation Insurance, injury claims are more likely to be filed by workers who fear for their job security and want to receive these benefits while they still are employed.

Alternatively, some employees may choose to defer claims for less technically severe injuries during the pandemic. As a result, there could be a surge in compensation claims once medical resources are not being prioritized to COVID-19 treatment. While hospitals remain inundated with coronavirus patients, this also contributes to delayed resolution on currently open claims.

Adding insult to injury, OSHA has also offered lackluster assistance to workers reporting unsafe workplace conditions. The government agency—designed to oversee occupational health and safety conditions—has actually loosened guidelines for nonmedical businesses during the pandemic. As a result, workers are experiencing lax viral protections and delayed compensation should they be injured on the job.

COVID-19 PPE Shortages: Who is Liable?

May 14 2020
To date, COVID-19 has killed over 71,000 Americans and infected over 1.2 million across the country. One of the biggest hurdles caused by the coronavirus pandemic has been shortages of COVID-19 personal protective equipment (PPE). These shortages have been especially…

04

Eligibility for COVID-19 Workers’ Compensation

For Essential, Nonessential, and Federal Workers

Essential Workers’ Eligibility 

Workers’ compensation insurance focuses specifically on covering illnesses and injuries sustained in a workplace environment. Employers offer this coverage either from state-run agencies or private insurance brokers. During the public health crisis, workplace injuries stemming from the novel coronavirus have been a constant concern for essential workers.

Contagion is a daily occupational threat, especially for frontline healthcare providers. Many states recognize the threat the coronavirus poses to the very services we deem essential. As such, states are moving to ensure their claims will be paid out. In California, Governor Gavin Newsom recently issued Executive Order N-62-20 which grants “rebuttable presumption” that an essential worker’s COVID-19 illness was contracted during the course of their employment, for the purpose of workers’ compensation. Similar workers’ compensation policies have been passed in Alaska, Arkansas, Illinois, Kentucky, Minnesota, Missouri, and Wisconsin.

Non-Essential Workers’ Eligibility

Nonessential workers may have a tougher time proving they contracted the virus directly through their work. According to the National Council on Compensation Insurance (NCCI), whether COVID-19 is compensable under state workers’ compensation acts is still an open question. The NCCI says, that “while workers compensation laws provide compensation for “occupational diseases” that arise out of and in the course of employment, many state statutes exclude “ordinary diseases of life” (e.g., the common cold or flu). There are occupational groups that arguably would have a higher probability for exposure such as healthcare workers. However, even in those cases, there may be uncertainty as to whether the disease is compensable.”

Federal Workers’ Eligibility for Workers’ Compensation

Under the Federal Employees’ Compensation Act (FECA), all federal employees who develop COVID-19 while in the performance of their federal duties are entitled to workers’ compensation coverage. This includes politicians, their staff members, military personnel, and numerous civilians, including postal workers.

Expert insights have never been more critical.

05

Considerations for Attorneys Pursuing COVID-19 Workers’ Compensation Cases

Workers’ compensation is largely considered an “exclusive remedy,” meaning claiming these benefits forfeits civil litigation against an employer. However, as employees come up against roadblocks to compensation, they may resort to far more aggressive action in the form of negligence suits seeking punitive damages.

Employer negligence and workers’ compensation coverage remain separate concerns in determining liability and damages during the coronavirus crisis. Yet the two questions are likely to arise simultaneously in a number of cases and should be considered together for the ways in which they impact one another.

For example, all COVID-19 workers compensation claimants will face the burden of proof: was their infection contracted while they were on the job? For essential workers, many states have already guaranteed these claims will be honored. For other nonessential workers, connecting the infection to a work-related cause may be a steeper undertaking.

Negligence claims levied against companies like Walmart and Amazon may also play a role in handling future COVID-19-related workers’ compensation claims, insofar as they become legal benchmarks to establish causational factors of a worker’s illness.

To illustrate, imagine a hypothetical lawsuit against Spectrum Cable by employees who caught COVID-19 after being told they had to work from the office. If this lawsuit establishes that working at the office was the cause of the employees’ illness, that fact may help support the employees’ separate workers’ compensation claim by showing that they contracted COVID-19 in the course of their work.

But given the current bottlenecks of the workers’ compensation process, employees may find employment class action built on exposure liability claims may be the preferred legal alternative. In fact, the U.S. Chamber of Commerce calls exposure liability, “largest area of concern for the overall business community” as the economy reopens. Though this liability will depend upon individual protections on a state by state basis, the volume of evidence presented in a class action format could prove reasonable causation of occupational coronavirus.

06

Expert Witnesses for COVID-19 Workers’ Compensation Cases

Many such claims will benefit from the inclusion of expert witnesses. Experts in epidemiology or infectious disease may establish the biological facts regarding how the coronavirus can spread in a workplace. Occupational health and safety experts, as well as OSHA experts, will also be critical to understanding where employers were lacking in their protective measures for employees. And of course, workers’ compensation experts will be key for comprehending coverage policies and how recent state legislation has altered these terms.

The number of coronavirus related claims for workers compensation coverage is likely to rise as long as the risk of contracting the virus remains prominent. Early consideration of the connections between workers’ compensation and other COVID-19 claims can help legal teams build a cohesive strategy to address them.

Expert E-006826
E-006826

Factory Safety Expert

This expert is an independent safety consultant out of the UK. For the past 27 years, he has worked in a variety of engineering environments to ensure that UK/EU safety standards were upheld. He is familiar with the UK factory safety standards and product safe design standards and has the appropriate experience to help with this case. He has worked large engineering companies to ensure their compliance with the Health and Safety at Work Act, CE Marking Directives and PUWER....

Expert E-008180
E-008180

Healthcare Management Expert

This highly qualified healthcare management expert has 20 years of experience in the field. He received a Masters in Health Administration from The Ohio State University and is a Certified Healthcare Executive. he was appointed as an Associate Graduate Faculty Member at Central Michigan University to teach aspects of Health Services Organizations in the Master of Science in Administration with concentration in Health Services Administration program. He has held several ...

Expert E-008595
E-008595

OSHA Expert

This expert is experienced with fatality, catastrophic injury and personal injury cases. He holds multiple certifications in occupational safety & health and OSHA compliance. Expertise includes forklifts, boom lifts, scissor lifts, fall protection, machine guarding, work zones, scaffolds, excavations. He specializes in applying OSHA General Industry regulations, OSHA Construction regulations, and safety-related national consensus standards to working conditions. He ...

Expert E-010639
E-010639

OSHA Safety Expert

This highly-qualified expert has 20+ years of experience in the occupational safety industry both as an educator and consultant in the field. She has 20 years of experience in safety management, 16 years in safety consulting, and 20 years of teaching safety courses at top ranking accredited Universities. She has a Masters from Indiana University in Occupational Health and Safety and a B.S. in Safety Management from Indiana University. She is licensed in Accident, ...

Expert E-013831
E-013831

Compensation Strategy and Policy Expert

This expert has more than 20 years of experience in the field of compensation, and is recognized worldwide for his global expertise in sales incentive plan design, as well as other kinds of variable reward and recognition programs. He has worked in both public and private sectors, and has a wide range of diversified industry experience that includes Finance, Managed Care, Food, Chemical and Durable Goods manufacturing. He has been an invited speaker at several ...

Expert E-007370
E-007370

Labor Analysis Expert

This expert has worked in labor analysis for over 35 years and has published extensively on the labor market. Previously, he worked at the U.S. Department of Labor where he received numerous Outstanding Performance/Secretary's Exceptional Achievement Awards. He has a PhD in the Economics of Human Resources and is currently Senior Consultant for an employment analysis firm. He has consulted and testified in cases for both defense and plaintiff clients, involving ...

Expert E-007614
E-007614

Occupational Health and Safety Expert

This expert has over 15 years of experience in occupational health and safety. His expertise includes construction safety, accident investigation, OSHA and ANSI standards, fall protection, ladders, scaffolds, aerial and scissor lifts and excavation. For the past seventeen years, he has taught for the Region II OSHA Education Centers & currently serves as course chairperson for eleven different courses. During his career, he has worked as an auditor, project manager and ...

Expert E-011958
E-011958

Environmental and Occupational Exposure & Pulmonary Expert

This extremely qualified expert is board certified in internal, occupational and pulmonary medicine and has been practicing for 29+ years. She completed her internship and residency training at Yale University before concluding two fellowships focusing on occupational, environmental, pulmonary and critical care medicine at Yale University and at the University of Washington. She is a fellow at both the American College of Chest Physicians and the American College of ...

Expert E-029200
E-029200

Machine Safeguarding and Energy Control Expert

This extremely qualified expert has years of experience in human factors, machine design and systems methodologies as they apply to the prevention of injury involving industrial and agricultural equipment. He received his MEA degree from George Washington University and his PhD degree in industrial engineering from West Virginia University. He is a member of multiple professional associations, including the American Society of Safety Engineers and the System Safety ...